fix(rank): retry postings that could not be fetched instead of expiring them (#564)

* fix(rank): retry postings that could not be fetched instead of expiring them

A posting /rank could not fetch (403, login wall, 404, timeout, empty
page) and one that is really closed both became `expired`, which is
terminal: `candidates` only selected `new`, so a transient failure on
ranking day removed a live job from the pipeline and the report
presented it as closed.

Shape per the maintainer's decisions on #534:

- Scoring agents return a third status, `unreachable` (with a short
  `fetch_error`), after exhausting the 09-web-research.md escalation
  order; `expired` stays for positive evidence of closure (closed page,
  410, redirect to a listing page, passed deadline). A 404 is
  `unreachable` first (#538 is that case).
- `candidates` selects `unreachable` alongside `new`. `apply` increments
  `fetch_attempts`, keeps `first_unreachable` (UTC timestamp) and stores
  `last_fetch_error` (short reason, no page text). After 3 attempts with
  at least 48 hours between the first and the last it writes `expired`
  with `expired_reason: "unreachable"` and returns the job once under
  `gave_up`, which Step 5 prints under "Gave up, check manually" with
  its URL. A later successful fetch, an explicit `expired` or a passed
  deadline clears the retry fields. `--all` still revives everything.
- rank_state.py owns the status set (`AGENT_STATUSES`); `apply` rejects
  any other status instead of reporting a misleading missing score, and
  test_rank_command.py asserts rank.md's JSON contract names the same
  set. A new `--now` option makes the 48-hour floor testable.
- rank.md's step text (Step 2 rules and contract, rule 6's --all note,
  Step 4 fields, Step 5 report, Important Rule 1) updated together.
  CHANGELOG under Changed: no existing entry carries the new status, so
  no migration.

Reported by @ai-tvang in #534, who also proposed the time floor and the
give-up listing.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(rank): expire an unreachable posting whose deadline has passed

Review on #564:

- The unreachable branch in apply returned before the deadline check the
  scored path runs, and candidates hands out `new` entries whose stored
  deadline has passed. So a posting that closed on 2026-09-20 and
  returned 403 on 2026-10-05 was retried, then listed under "Gave up,
  check manually" as possibly live. A passed stored deadline is now
  checked first and takes the expired path, dropping the retry fields,
  as on master and under rule 5. New test pins it.
- 09-web-research.md step 5 said that in /rank an unretrievable posting
  is marked `expired`, so an agent following it could write a 403 off
  and bring #534 back. It now says `unreachable` (framework_version
  1.1.2 -> 1.1.3); the CHANGELOG entry says so.
- The report shows `attempt N` instead of `N/3`, which read 4/3 while a
  job waited out the 48-hour floor, and job-scraper's dedup note names
  `unreachable` alongside `ranked`/`expired`.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Nishil RathodandClaude Opus 5.5 authored and GitHub committed 2026-10-17 19:46:06 +02:00
1 parent 011a8b8435
commit a203bdd08f
7 files changed
+330 -21

No files matched your search

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
---
framework_version: 1.1.2
framework_version: 1.1.3
---
# Web Research and Fetching
@@ -89,7 +89,7 @@ Try these in order and stop at the first that yields real content:
2. **`WebFetch`** on the target URL (for non-portal URLs, or if the portal CLI is missing or failed). Cheapest for general web pages, returns clean markdown.
3. **Check `robots.txt`, then `curl` with browser headers** (above), then strip tags. Fixes the 403 class of failure. If `robots.txt` disallows the path for `*` or `Claude-User`, **skip this step entirely** and go to step 4.
4. **`WebSearch`** for the company or role by name, to find an alternative canonical URL: the employer's own careers portal is almost always richer than the aggregator that surfaced the posting, and it carries the reference ID and grade that aggregators drop.
5. **Declare it genuinely unavailable** only after 1 to 4 have failed. In `/rank` that means marking the entry `expired`; in `/apply` it means telling the user the posting could not be retrieved and stopping rather than drafting from the title.
5. **Declare it genuinely unavailable** only after 1 to 4 have failed. In `/rank` that means marking the entry `unreachable`, which later runs retry (`expired` is only for a posting shown to be closed - see `rank.md` Step 2); in `/apply` it means telling the user the posting could not be retrieved and stopping rather than drafting from the title.
### Login walls are a different failure